Combining Open & Closed Rhinoplasty: TRICK-TIP Technique for Nasal Tip Preservation
Rhinoplasty is one of the most complex and transformative procedures in aesthetic surgery, with outcomes that significantly influence both function and aesthetics. While traditional approaches such as open and closed rhinoplasty have long been the cornerstones of practice, each comes with distinct advantages and limitations. The TRICK-TIP (Transcolumellar and Inter-Cartilaginous Keystoning with Tip Preservation) rhinoplasty technique, introduced by Dr. Francisco Villegas-Alzate, merges these two methods to maximize visibility and precision while preserving the delicate anatomy of the nasal tip. This technique is revolutionizing rhinoplasty, offering a versatile and minimally invasive solution for diverse nasal deformities.
What Is the TRICK-TIP Rhinoplasty Technique?
At its core, TRICK-TIP rhinoplasty is designed to preserve the nasal tip’s natural contours and relationships while enhancing access for precise modifications. Unlike traditional open rhinoplasty, which involves separating the skin from the cartilage at the nasal tip, TRICK-TIP lifts the nasal tip as a composite three-layered flap. This innovative method avoids disrupting the skin-cartilage interface, ensuring structural integrity and maintaining blood supply.
The technique is named after its combined surgical approach: Transcolumellar and Inter-Cartilaginous Keystoning. By blending open and closed rhinoplasty techniques, surgeons can achieve extensive visibility without the extensive scarring or prolonged recovery associated with traditional methods.
How Is the Procedure Performed?
The TRICK-TIP rhinoplasty technique follows a structured and innovative surgical protocol that ensures optimal access while maintaining the natural anatomy of the nasal tip. Below is a detailed step-by-step breakdown of the procedure, along with key insights and considerations for achieving successful outcomes:
1. Incision Design and Initial Access
A stairstep incision is made in the lower third of the columella, near the crural footplates and just above the labio-columellar crease. This incision is carefully positioned to minimize visible scarring postoperatively.
Bilateral intercartilaginous incisions are performed to create an access point for elevating the nasal tip. These incisions are strategically placed to avoid damaging surrounding tissues and maintain vascular integrity.
Tip: The positioning of the stairstep incision is crucial to preserving the natural contour of the columella. Surgeons should ensure precise alignment to avoid asymmetry or irregularities.
2. Elevation of the Composite Flap
The nasal tip and columella are elevated as a three-layered composite chondrocutaneous flap, which includes skin, cartilage, and the underlying mucosa. This elevation allows for extensive visibility of the nasal pyramid and septum.
No dissection occurs between the alar cartilages and the overlying skin, preserving the natural anatomical relationships.
Tip: The integrity of the flap must be maintained during elevation to prevent damage to the delicate skin-cartilage interface. Gentle handling is essential to minimize the risk of vascular compromise.
3. Exposure and Dissection
In the cartilaginous vault, a supra-perichondral dissection is preferred. This approach maintains the integrity of the upper lateral cartilages and prevents ruptures during maneuvers like chondroplasty, spreader grafts, or spreader flap placement.
In the bony nasal vault, subperiosteal dissection is performed, starting laterally and progressing medially. Efforts are made to preserve the periosteum wherever possible, reducing trauma and ensuring stable healing.
Tip: The supra-perichondral plane offers a safer and more predictable dissection pathway, reducing the risk of cartilage rupture and ensuring smooth transitions during modifications.
4. Tip Modifications
Retrograde trimming of the lateral crura or domal cartilage is performed as needed. This step is executed from beneath, ensuring precise reshaping of the tip without separating the skin from the cartilage.
A columellar strut is often used to provide key support. The strut is sutured between the medial crura and anchored to the anterior nasal spine. The height and projection of the strut are adjusted intraoperatively to achieve the desired tip projection.
Any supratip dead space is closed using sutures that unite the skin to the underlying cartilage. This ensures a smooth contour and reduces the risk of supratip deformity.
Tip: Tip modifications require careful intraoperative judgment. Over-resection of cartilage can lead to pinched tips, while under-resection may result in inadequate definition.
5. Addressing Specific Nasal Deformities
Dorsal Modifications: If necessary, the dorsal hump is removed, and the cartilaginous vault is remodeled using spreader grafts or flaps. Proper alignment of the osseocartilaginous junction prevents step deformities and maintains a smooth dorsal contour.
Alar Flaring: In cases of excessive alar flaring, resection is performed. A stitch is placed in the nasal sill to narrow the nostrils, followed by transfixing “U” sutures for final contouring.
Tip: Alar modifications should be conservative to prevent over-reduction, which could lead to nostril asymmetry or functional breathing issues.
6. Wound Closure and Final Adjustments
Closure begins with the intercartilaginous incisions, followed by the membranous septum and the columellar skin. Absorbable sutures are used for a clean and scar-free outcome.
If necessary, external quilting sutures are applied to address floppy skin or excessive bleeding.
Tip The closure sequence should be precise to avoid tension on the sutures, which could compromise healing or create visible scars.
7. Postoperative Care and Follow-Up
A dorsal splint is applied for immobilization, and porous paper taping is used to maintain the newly sculpted nasal contours. Anterior nasal packing is avoided to enhance patient comfort.
Postoperative follow-up includes regular visits to monitor healing and address any concerns, such as swelling or minor asymmetries.
Considerations During Surgery
Vascular Safety: Preserving the vascular network in the columella and tip is critical. Excessive handling of the columellar skin or aggressive resection can compromise blood supply, increasing the risk of necrosis.
Avoiding Over-Manipulation: Over-resection of cartilage or excessive modifications can lead to complications like alar rim collapse or tip pinching. Surgeons should aim for conservative adjustments to maintain structural integrity.
Intraoperative Judgment: The technique relies heavily on real-time decision-making for elements like the placement of the columellar strut and the use of supratip sutures. Surgeons must be adept at assessing skin and cartilage behavior intraoperatively.
Balancing Aesthetics and Function: While aesthetic refinement is a primary goal, functional considerations like maintaining airway patency must not be overlooked.
Managing Complex Cases: Secondary or reconstructive cases may present scar tissue or disrupted anatomy, requiring modifications to the standard TRICK-TIP approach.
When Should TRICK-TIP Be Used?
This technique is particularly effective for:
Primary Rhinoplasty Cases: Patients requiring modifications to the dorsal hump, nasal sidewalls, or septal deviations.
Moderate Nasal Deformities: Cases where natural tip definition and subtle reshaping are the primary goals.
Patients Seeking Minimal Scarring: Those who prioritize natural aesthetics with no visible external scars.
When Is It Not Recommended?
While versatile, TRICK-TIP rhinoplasty has limitations:
Complex Secondary Rhinoplasty: In cases requiring extensive alar cartilage reconstruction or precise tip manipulation, traditional open approaches may offer greater flexibility.
Severe Structural Deformities: Situations demanding multiple cartilage grafts or complex
reconstructions may exceed the scope of this technique.
Surgeons must carefully assess the patient’s anatomy and procedural goals to determine whether TRICK-TIP is the ideal approach.
Surgical Outcomes of TRICK-TIP Rhinoplasty
The outcomes of TRICK-TIP rhinoplasty have been highly favorable, as demonstrated in a study of 120 patients. The procedure achieved high satisfaction rates with minimal complications. Highlights include:
Patient Satisfaction: Patients reported a median satisfaction score of 100/100 using the validated FACE-Q questionnaire, highlighting excellent results in both aesthetics and quality of life.
Low Complication Rates: No cases of skin necrosis, hematoma, or gross asymmetry were reported, and revisions were required in only 3.3% of cases.
Natural Aesthetics: External evaluators rated the procedure highly, with low deformity scores for nostrils, soft triangles, and columellar scars (averaging 1.73 or below on a five-point scale).
These results underscore the technique’s ability to achieve predictable, aesthetically pleasing, and complication-free outcomes.
Advantages of TRICK-TIP Rhinoplasty
The TRICK-TIP rhinoplasty technique offers several advantages, making it an innovative approach in nasal surgery. Here’s a closer look at how these advantages are achieved:
Preservation of Anatomy
The TRICK-TIP technique avoids separating the skin from the nasal tip cartilage. By elevating the tip as a composite three-layered chondrocutaneous flap, it preserves the skin-cartilage interface and the surrounding vascular network. This reduces trauma and ensures the blood supply remains intact, decreasing the risk of complications like skin necrosis or alar rim deformities.
Preservation of these structures allows for more natural postoperative tip contours, reducing the risk of over-manipulation or deformity. It also facilitates revisions or secondary procedures if needed, as the original anatomy remains largely intact.
Reduced Recovery Time
Minimal dissection in the columellar and tip regions reduces soft tissue swelling and tissue trauma during surgery. Additionally, the technique avoids excessive handling of the columellar and vestibular skin, which further reduces inflammatory responses.
Patients benefit from faster recovery with less postoperative swelling and bruising. This translates into improved patient satisfaction, as they can return to normal activities sooner while observing the aesthetic results earlier.
Minimal Scarring
The low stairstep incision is strategically placed near the labio-columellar crease, where scars are naturally less visible. Furthermore, the procedure limits external dissection, avoiding large visible scars commonly associated with traditional open rhinoplasty.
The scar is imperceptible in most patients, which is particularly appealing for those who prioritize natural aesthetics. This advantage is especially significant in cultures where visible scars are less acceptable.
Versatile Application
The combination of open and closed rhinoplasty principles allows for enhanced visibility and access to the nasal dorsum and septum while maintaining structural preservation. Surgeons can address deformities such as dorsal humps, nasal sidewall irregularities, and septal deviations without compromising tip anatomy.
The technique is suitable for a wide range of primary rhinoplasty cases and even some secondary cases where significant grafting is not required. It provides flexibility for surgeons to adapt to patient-specific needs.
Natural-Looking Results
By maintaining the natural union between the alar cartilages and overlying skin, the technique avoids the disruption that can lead to irregularities in tip definition. Modifications such as retrograde cartilage trimming and minimal soft tissue resections are performed with precision from beneath, ensuring a balanced tip projection and contour.
The results are harmonious and aesthetically pleasing, with reduced risks of tip-related complications like over-projection or pinching, often seen in more aggressive approaches.
Limitations of TRICK-TIP Rhinoplasty
Despite its many advantages, the TRICK-TIP technique has limitations, particularly in certain cases that require more extensive modifications or intricate corrections:
Learning Curve for Surgeons
Surgeons accustomed to traditional open or closed rhinoplasty methods may find it challenging to adapt to the composite flap elevation and the indirect approach to tip modifications. Achieving precise cartilage trimming and suturing from below requires advanced surgical dexterity.
In inexperienced hands, the risk of incomplete correction or asymmetry may increase. Surgeons must undergo adequate training and gain proficiency in the technique to ensure consistent outcomes.
Limited Suitability for Complex Secondary Cases
Secondary rhinoplasty cases often involve significant scar tissue, disrupted anatomy, or the need for extensive cartilage grafting. The TRICK-TIP technique’s emphasis on preservation may limit access or visibility in cases where precise reconstruction of the nasal framework is required.
In these situations, traditional open approaches may be more appropriate as they allow for direct visualization and manipulation of scarred or compromised structures.
Challenges with Severe Structural Deformities
The TRICK-TIP technique is not ideal for cases requiring large grafts or major structural changes, such as in patients with severe congenital deformities, significant asymmetries, or major trauma sequelae. The limited dissection approach may restrict the ability to place and secure extensive grafts effectively.
In such cases, the technique may fall short in delivering the structural support or dramatic reshaping required, necessitating an alternative surgical approach.
Risk of Over-Reliance on Intraoperative Adjustments
The technique relies heavily on intraoperative adjustments, such as the placement of a columellar strut or sutures to obliterate the supratip dead space. While these adjustments are effective, they may leave less room for precise preoperative planning and simulation.
Surgeons need to exercise strong judgment during surgery, as over- or under-correction of these elements can compromise the final result.
Potential for Limited Visibility in Complex Modifications
Although TRICK-TIP improves visibility compared to closed rhinoplasty, it may still fall short of the comprehensive exposure provided by traditional open rhinoplasty in cases requiring intricate dorsal or tip reconstruction.
Surgeons may struggle to address deeper or more complex deformities with the same level of accuracy, potentially requiring additional surgical interventions.
How Does It Compare to Other Methods?
Open Rhinoplasty: Offers unparalleled access but risks visible scarring and prolonged recovery.
Closed Rhinoplasty: Minimally invasive but lacks the visibility needed for intricate modifications.
TRICK-TIP Rhinoplasty: Combines the best of both worlds, providing the visibility of open rhinoplasty with the tissue preservation of closed rhinoplasty, making it ideal for most moderate deformities.
Conclusion
The TRICK-TIP rhinoplasty technique is a significant advancement in nasal surgery, offering surgeons a versatile, minimally invasive method to achieve natural and lasting results. By combining the precision of open rhinoplasty with the preservation benefits of closed techniques, it addresses many of the limitations associated with traditional approaches.
For surgeons eager to adopt innovative techniques, TRICK-TIP rhinoplasty is a compelling choice that prioritizes patient outcomes, reduces complications, and enhances surgical efficiency. As this method gains traction, it may set a new standard in the field of aesthetic rhinoplasty.
Reference:
Villegas-Alzate, F. The TRICK-TIP Rhinoplasty: Tip of the Nose Preservation Using the Combined Synergy of Open and Closed Approaches. Aesth Plast Surg 48, 3098–3108 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00266-024-03901-w
Learn techniques behind Rhinoplasty and Facial Bone Contouring
in our upcoming Mini Fellowship:
IFAAS Mini-Fellowship (Observational)
Asian Rhinoplasty & Facial Bone Contouring
March 17-19, 2025 - Seoul, South Korea - [Register Now]
More Upcoming Global Events